Well if everyone did it on their own blogspot account then this whole separate forum idea would be a bit pointless wouldn't it?

Now that this additional forum has been opened, it would be nice to be able to keep it going. I agree with others, and don't see any real problems with having the critique in the original thread. If anyone is unsatisfied and want to revise their writing then they can just use the edit button. If it's a complete rework then I guess they can make a new thread and close the original.